American Airlines’ next widebody order “could go either way” between Airbus and Boeing despite the US manufacturer benefiting from commonality with the carrier’s existing long-haul fleet, according to chief commercial officer Nat Pieper.
The airline is currently considering its future widebody requirements after chief executive Robert Isom revealed in June that it had issued a request for proposals (RFP) and was in talks with both aircraft manufacturers.
American’s ageing fleet of 47 777-200ERs are the target for renewal. They are part of a 137-strong all-Boeing widebody fleet which also includes 20 777-300ERs, 37 787-8s and 33 787-9s.
Despite the dominance of Boeing, Pieper insisted this did not present an insurmountable barrier to Airbus.
“I think there is an economic benefit to commonality,” Pieper told Airliner World at the airline’s 777-300ER retrofit cabin launch event at Dallas/Forth Worth. “I’ve been buying airplanes for a lot of my career. It can economically be overcome.”
Describing how American assesses competing aircraft, he added: “If you have that row in the spreadsheet that says commonality benefit, Boeing clearly gets some points for that. Airbus doesn’t, but there are a lot of different ways Airbus could make that up.
“So we feel really good about it, it could go either way.”
When asked about how close a decision on a replacement was, Pieper told FlightGlobal that American was in the “seventh or eighth innings” – in reference to baseball’s nine innings.
American previously operated 24 Airbus A330s, inherited through its 2013 merger with US Airways, but withdrew the last examples in 2020.
Pieper said the carrier was looking for the aircraft best suited to its future network rather than limiting its options to its incumbent widebody manufacturer.
“Boeing’s done a great job with 787s and 777s, and we’re in a widebody campaign featuring both Airbus and Boeing,” he explained.
“We want the best airplane that’s suited to the missions we’re going to fly. There clearly are commonality benefits, but on the other hand each airplane has unique characteristics, and so you want to just pick the right airplane or airplanes for the markets which we want to fly.”
He added that there was “no stigma” within American surrounding a potential return to Airbus widebodies, saying: “We might.”
Robert Isom previously said the latest fleet evaluation was being undertaken with the retirement of American’s Boeing 777s expected to begin in the 2030s, with lengthy widebody production lead times prompting the carrier to begin defining its requirements now.
Asked specifically about the Boeing 777X, Pieper was more cautious, although he stressed that his comments represented a personal view rather than American’s position.
“I tend to be one that is wary of large aircraft,” he said. “I would rather aircraft get out there, fly [and] let somebody [else take them].
“It may be amazing out of the box – and this isn’t specific on the 777X, it’s just life in general that it is much better to let others take the airplane, work through it, and then down the line, if it makes sense for us, we would look at it.”

